Let's face it--there's a dilemma. There are artists out there who really desire some balanced feedback on their work. The good, the bad--the works. And then there are viewers, who are too afraid of getting flipped out on to give such balanced feedback. This group is hopefully a fix to that problem.

Here's the deal--anything you want critique on, you submit. This'll give an O-K sign to all us folks that you want both the good and the bad on a piece. What works and what doesn't.

RULES:
For the critics--
1) In almost every picture, there is both good and bad. Try to point out both what is working and what isn't on a piece--after all, if the artist has something really good going on in an otherwise not-so-good piece, they shouldn't completely drop what good thing they have going on.
2) Critiquing does not give you an excuse to be cruel. No one is learning anything from a "this sucks" comment. :(

For the artists--
1) As tempting as it is, please don't get defensive about your work. We're trying to help. If you know you tend to be protective of your work, read a comment, wait about 15 minutes and look over your picture, then respond. It can help. :3
2) Try not to spam up the club. Submitting 3-4 pictures close to each other is okay, but try not to submit 15+ pictures all at once.

 

 

Ask me a question :-)

|

 

 

 

Yes